RSN
Home
News
Watch
Tips
NZ Racing
Win

AFL

22 hours ago

Cornes: Disallowed Watson goal “dumbest” decision of the year

By SEN

Image

Kane Cornes is not happy with the goal that was taken off Hawthorn’s Nick Watson at half-time of Thursday night’s win over St Kilda.

The Hawks small forward nailed a set shot after the siren at Marvel Stadium which was disallowed as he was adjudged to have run off his line.

The decision had little impact on the game, as the Hawks won by 52 points, but it has attracted the ire of Cornes who has labelled it the “dumbest” and “most ridiculous” decision of the year.

“I’ve seen all the vision that’s available to me. I’ve seen the broadcast vision, I’ve seen it in HD multiple times,” Cornes aid on SEN’s Fireball.

“It’s the dumbest, most ridiculous decision you will see all year. Anyone who wants to argue that I think is ridiculous.”

Cornes attempted to make sense of exactly why the Watson goal was disallowed.

“One of the more bizarre umpiring decisions that I've ever seen. Ever,” Cornes continued.

“I think there needs to be a statement as to what has happened there and the AFL admitting that that was an umpire error, surely.

“We cannot be having goals, which are pretty important, overturned like that last night at half-time.

“I’d be very surprised if that was ever paid in a Grand Final and I don't know what was going through the umpire's head because he's right there. I just do not know what he was thinking in that moment.

“I guess there needs to be more ramifications for decisions like that. That's a strange thing to do. I couldn't quite get my head around it.”

Co-host David King was broadcasting for Fox Footy and spoke to Watson after the game.

“He was pretty angry about it actually. He was just a bit confused and a bit angry,” said King.

“He felt that, without putting words in his mouth, they were just happy to blow the whistle. The umpire just wanted to get involved was basically what he was saying, which I kind of agree with.

“Just let the players sort it out. Let the game sort itself out. I just think we're getting a lot of random intervention at the moment, whether it's the reviews or whether it's the last touch out of bounds stuff, the goal-line stuff, just the incorrect calls, lack of feel for the game.”

Cornes is adamant that Greg Swann, the AFL’s Executive General Manager Football Performance, would not be overly pleased with such a call.

“The AFL would know in their hearts that was the wrong call last night,” he said further.

“Imagine Swanny watching that vision. He’s a good footy person, he knows what decision should be made.

“There is no way, if we know Greg Swann the way that we do, that he would be supportive of that decision.

“So I think for them to come out publicly and say that was the right call, we’ll see right through that, if that’s the way they’re going to go. And I don’t think they will.”

Hawks coach sam Mitchell admits the club will seek clarification about such a decision.

“We'll certainly be going to the AFL to ask about it,” Mitchell said at his post-match press conference.

“It makes sense to me that that is a rule on the other side of the ground. As a right-footer, there is absolutely no reason that a player would go wider to give themselves an advantage, and that's what the rule is there for

“And it makes sense, but the vision doesn't look like he goes off his line much, but that's the umpire's call and I can accept that. But the fact that you can go off the line towards the boundary and it be called play on, there's no common sense about that.

“So, I would hope that we get an answer from the AFL, and I'm sure we will, they've been very good at giving us answers and giving us adjustments, they've done that really well. When something doesn't make sense, they fix it pretty quickly. So, why would he run wider to give himself a harder shot and it get called play on? Didn't make a lot of sense.

“I’m glad it was in a game where individual tiny scores didn't matter, but I hope that's something they rectify.”

Sign up to RSN's Newsletter

Sign up to the up-to-date with the latest news, events and special offers.

Sign Up